Speaking of Standards

“Why do you write so much about P2P SIP? Who’s really going to use it? Why do you care? Isn’t it really just a lame attempt to create an open standards version of Skype?”

As you might imagine, I’ve heard those questions more than a few times. And yet still I keep writing about it. Why? Part of the answer lies in my post back in December… today the world of SIP is all really “client/server” but the future might be quite different. Today you have SIP user agents that register and connect to SIP servers (which might be SIP proxies, SIP registrars or other types of servers). In fact, our own Prophecy product is a powerful SIP application server. Our Evolution developer portal is a massive SIP-application-server-in-the-cloud (more here) that connects to and from SIP clients.

But now imagine a SIP deployment without servers.

Imagine that you could simply distribute a series of SIP phones and have them all rapidly interconnect to each other and start communicating. Think of how fast you could potentially deploy a small office. In this time of US presidential campaigns, I think of the “advance teams” that are dropped into some office space in some city to organize an area. Imagine if they could be given a bunch of phones which just self-organized into a working communication environment? Plug the phones into a network switch and have them sort out extensions, PSTN gateways, all of that. There are all sorts of similar situations. Teams of consultants or auditors. Emergency environments. Short-term branch offices. Outside of the rapid deployment, there are just general uses in small businesses that don’t want to pay for servers. You could even see it being used in a home environment. Today this kind of thing can be done with “teleworker” phones hooked back to a central IP-PBX or hosted service (I know because I helped launch one back in 2003), but what if it could be even easier?

This is the promise of P2P SIP. Take a bunch of SIP endpoints and they form their own P2P “cloud” (or “overlay network” in P2P lingo). They discover resources like PSTN gateways or application servers. If a phone dies, the P2P cloud routes around it and continues. Communication happens.

Now the reality is not quite there today. There is a great amount of work being done within the IETF on this subject through the P2PSIP Working Group. There are P2PSIP implementations (mostly open source and a few commercial). There is a great amount of academic research going on (one example here). It is all still early days, though.

And on one level, that is what is so exciting. We are re-imagining what a network could be. We are pushing the power and intelligence truly out to the very edge of the network.

We are creating clouds.

Local clouds. Self-organizing clouds. Network “clouds” that connect to other clouds. It’s a different mindset… a different paradigm… thinking of networks not in terms of servers with their clients but in terms of nodes able to communicate with other nodes.

Will it work on a large scale? We’ll see… there’s a whole whack of security issues… privacy issues… scalability issues… but people are looking at those issues. Skype has certainly shown that a P2P telephony environment can be created and can be quite successful. (Although it should be noted that purists might not consider Skype a pure P2P network because they do have enrollment servers that deal with authentication, etc.) Other P2P networks for file sharing have shown the potential is there to build massively scalable networks. The building blocks are all around us.

So what’s the Voxeo angle, eh? Why do I care about it?

Two answers, really. First, there is the basic reality that just because you are creating a new way of connecting a telephony system it doesn’t remove the need for voice application services. You still want to run voice applications. You still need IVR systems. You still need ways to mashup voice with web services. You still need to connect to the PSTN. Some of those services may be able to live within the actual P2P cloud. Some of them will need to be in external servers or services. Obviously that’s what we do and so my interest is in how our software and services might play in this evolving space.

Second, it’s all about clouds. While there is a huge buzz these days about “cloud computing” and “virtualization“, this is what we’ve been doing here at Voxeo since our founding back in 1999! You can go right now to our Evolution developer portal, create your free account and start building voice applications that run in our massively distributed computing cloud. Behind the scenes, there’s a massively-scalable, geographically-distributed, open-standards-based, redundant (and, incidentally, patented) network architecture that virtualizes your voice and IVR applications. You have no idea what server your voice apps are running on and you don’t care. Need more ports… need more CPU cycles… the cloud adjusts for all of that. It’s all transparent to you.

Our “cloud” is then connected out into other “clouds”. You can connect to our cloud from the PSTN, SIP or Skype and then go back out to the PSTN or SIP clouds. We’re part of the massive interconnect currently being built online.

So as there is the potential to create local P2P “clouds”, my interest on multiple levels is pretty basic - how do we connect those small local clouds to our larger cloud and from there to the rest of the interconnected voice and data networks? I want to look at how our services can enable the proliferation of P2P SIP clouds.

Sure, large numbers of “production” deployments of P2P SIP are probably 3-5 years out… maybe even longer (but maybe not). At the current time there’s not a whole lot I can really do except engage in the ongoing conversations about P2P SIP and try to see what where it’s going. But that’s what I and my colleagues in our Office of the CTO do. We’re the guys up in the crow’s nest looking out and scanning the horizon for what’s coming next. Companies that expect to be around have to keep doing that. So that’s what I do. And that’s why I write about P2P SIP and why I’ll keep writing about it.

It’s all about the clouds… and how we connect them all together…

Technorati Tags: p2p, p2psip, sip, ietf, clouds, cloudcomputing, virtualization, ivr virtualization, peer to peer, skype, voxeo, voip, voice

Tags: IETF, P2P, P2PSIP, SIP

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.